How. Does. This. Keep. Happening.
What you need to know
- A report indicates that Facebook was paying third parties to transcribe Messenger audio conversations.
- The conversations were anonymous and often « vulgar. »
- Facebook says it has since stopped this human review process.
Were you sitting there to yourself and thinking, « Gee, it’s been too long since Facebook screwed up? » Me neither, but that’s exactly what’s happened. Again. According to a report from Bloomberg, Facebook has been paying hundreds of third-party contractors to listen to and transcribe audio conversations from Facebook Messenger.
This news came to light on August 13, with the report saying:
The work has rattled the contract employees, who are not told where the audio was recorded or how it was obtained — only to transcribe it, said the people, who requested anonymity for fear of losing their jobs. They’re hearing Facebook users’ conversations, sometimes with vulgar content, but do not know why Facebook needs them transcribed, the people said.
Facebook claims that it has since stopped this transcription process and « will no longer do so. »
In a statement, the company said:
Much like Apple and Google, we paused human review of audio more than a week ago.
The report continues:
Facebook hasn’t disclosed to users that third parties may review their audio. That’s led some contractors to feel their work is unethical, according to the people with knowledge of the matter.
At least one firm reviewing user conversations is TaskUs Inc., a Santa Monica, California-based outsourcing firm with outposts around the world, the people said. Facebook is one of TaskUs’s largest and most important clients, but employees aren’t allowed to mention publicly who their work is for. They call the client by the code name « Prism. »
While this is bad enough on its own and considering the other multiple privacy concerns Facebook has been regularly facing, it’s even more damning when you take into account CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s comments from his Congressional testimony that took place back in April 2018.
Speaking to Senator Gary Peters, Zuckerberg said:
You’re talking about this conspiracy theory that gets passed around that we listen to what’s going on on your microphone and use that for ads. We don’t do that.
To its credit, Facebook was transcribing the audio to improve its AI’s ability to interpret messages and not necessarily push ads. Furthermore, people that had their conversations transcribed « chose the option in Facebook’s Messenger app to have their voice chats transcribed. »
Even so, it’s hard to not feel a little dirty when you add this on top of a growing pile of privacy and security controversies we’ve seen in just this past year.